Wednesday 19 August 2015

How to recognise a False Teacher, Titus 1



 

Titus 1New American Standard Bible (NASB)

Salutation

1 Paul, a bond-servant of God and an apostle of Jesus Christ, [a]for the faith of those chosen of God and the knowledge of the truth which is according to godliness, 2 in the hope of eternal life, which God, who cannot lie, promised [b]long ages ago, 3 but at the proper time manifested, even His word, in the proclamation with which I was entrusted according to the commandment of God our Saviour,

4 To Titus, my true child [c]in a common faith: Grace and peace from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Saviour.

Qualifications of Elders

5 For this reason I left you in Crete, that you would set in order what remains and appoint elders in every city as I directed you, 6 namely, if any man is above reproach, the husband of one wife, having children who believe, not accused of dissipation or rebellion. 7 For the [d]overseer must be above reproach as God’s steward, not self-willed, not quick-tempered, not addicted to wine, not pugnacious, not fond of sordid gain, 8 but hospitable, loving what is good, sensible, just, devout, self-controlled, 9 holding fast the faithful word which is in accordance with the teaching, so that he will be able both to exhort in sound doctrine and to refute those who contradict.

10 For there are many rebellious men, empty talkers and deceivers, especially those of the circumcision, 11 who must be silenced because they are upsetting whole families, teaching things they should not teach for the sake of sordid gain. 12 One of themselves, a prophet of their own, said, “Cretans are always liars, evil beasts, lazy gluttons.” 13 This testimony is true. For this reason reprove them severely so that they may be sound in the faith, 14 not paying attention to Jewish myths and commandments of men who turn away from the truth. 15 To the pure, all things are pure; but to those who are defiled and unbelieving, nothing is pure, but both their mind and their conscience are defiled. 16 They profess to know God, but by their deeds they deny Him, being detestable and disobedient and worthless for any good deed.

The IVP New Testament Commentary Series
Greeting (1:1-4)

How many of us really know who we are and why we are here? Of course, we all have names and our own personal histories. We have goals, dreams and characteristics which we feel give us a special identity, and these things are certainly to be valued. But when we think about reason for being, personal identity and meaning in life, do we do so with God and his will in mind?

The letter to Titus lays that challenge, among others, before us today. Much of the letter encourages rather ordinary believers, who occupy all walks of life, to consider their lives in every facet as an expression of the will of God. In fact, once life is considered in this way, the thought of "ordinariness" departs from Christian thinking about life. No matter what path God has given us to walk, we are intended to be a vital piece in God's missionary plan to reach the rest of the world. Each "piece" has meaning, each human life has inestimable value and usefulness to God, and this realization is a tremendous source of joy, satisfaction and peace. But to comprehend this, we may need to make some adjustments in the way we view life. Let's begin, then, with a look at how Paul defined his own life. Although he was an apostle, the pattern of his thinking ought also to be ours.

As he does in the opening greeting of 1 Timothy, Paul again identifies formally his status and his office and then identifies and blesses the intended recipient. In comparison with 1 Timothy, however, the apostle, using very compact language, describes in more detail his Christian raison d'etre. This sets the tone and introduces the main theme of the letter.


Opposing False Teachers (1:10-16)

Having concluded the list of qualifications for the elder with a reference to refuting error, Paul goes on to unmask the false teachers in the Cretan church. These opponents of Paul must have arisen soon after the churches were planted, but we cannot be certain exactly how this came about.

Heresy involves more than simply teaching an unorthodox doctrine. Just as the Christian message affects the whole life, heresy left unchecked penetrates deep into the community's and the individual's life and thought, leaving nothing undisturbed. But its subtle beginnings and secretive motives often make it undetectable until it has surfaced as a movement with increasing momentum. For this reason Paul identifies and unequivocally denounces the false teachers and their doctrine.
The False Teachers

What kind of people would, in the name of Christianity, oppose the true faith? Paul's indictment of them, which is designed to expose and discredit them completely, begins by revealing some tell tale clues of heresy.

Far from being innocent seekers of truth, verse 10 portrays false teachers as willful and culpable. Rebellious (see v. 6; 1 Tim 1:9) describes them as consciously defiant and in opposition to Paul's authority and work. Paul characterizes their activity as "idle" or "mere talk," a reference both to their meaningless speculation and discussions and to the pagan quality of their "knowledge" (1 Tim 1:6). But it is as deceivers (v. 10) that false teachers do their most dangerous work; they willfully lead others astray. Paul's language places them into the same category as the heretics in Ephesus, who, by misrepresenting God's law and causing others to break it, come under its condemnation (1 Tim 1:8-10).

The description those of the circumcision (v. 10) provides a clue to the identity of those troubling the Cretan churches. As the term's use elsewhere suggests, the troublemakers were Jewish converts (Acts 10:45; 11:2; Gal 2:7-9, 12). Earlier Paul opposed Jewish believers in Galatia who were teaching the need to return to the ceremonies of the law to achieve righteousness. While this is not the same group, nor precisely the same teaching (see below), we can at least see that the influences of Judaism on the church had not yet ceased.

Paul's description is too brief to make absolutely plain the meaning of ruining whole households by teaching things they ought not to teach (v. 11). This may be a reference to the turning of whole house churches to the heresy, or possibly some part of their doctrine challenged traditional concepts concerning the household. To judge from 2:1-10, their teaching may have spawned a disregard for the accepted patterns of behavior in the various social relationships. Either way, the word whole here suggests that the influence of this doctrine was thorough. In Ephesus disruptions resulted from a misunderstanding of salvation and the times, and something similar may have been at work in Crete. These false teachers disrupted the unity of the church and endangered the church's reputation with those outside, who valued highly the traditional social structure.

False teachers can also be detected by their false motives. These "Christian" teachers in Crete were seeking to make a profit from their ministry. Such financial motives expose the false teacher's selfish desire to benefit more than the hearers from the "ministry" (compare 1 Tim 6:5-10).

The description Paul has thus far given has drawn out the obvious faults of the false teachers. When their attitudes, methods and motives are exposed, there can be no doubt that these people are evil. Paul puts the cap on this expose with his surprising quotation of Epimenides (v. 12). He calls this ancient religious teacher, from the sixth century B.C., one of their own [that is, the false teachers'] prophets. This first connection probably lies in their common profession, teaching religious fables, and in their common homeland, Crete. But how does Paul mean the citation to be understood? Cretans had acquired the name liars because of their claim that the tomb of Zeus was on Crete. Thus a reference to religious deceit is at the heart of the saying. These false teachers have fulfilled Epimenides' prophecy in their own generation by propagating a religious lie. The rest of the quotation, evil brutes, lazy gluttons, associates the false religious claim with uncontrolled, wanton behavior. Notice how closely Paul's description of the errorists corresponds to the three-part saying: they are deceivers (v. 10), rebels and disrupters (vv. 10-11), with minds set on money (v. 11). Clearly, in the case of these Cretan heretics, the ancient forecast held true. Today the religious lies propagated by cult leaders (those that draw attention away from the gospel) belong to the same category. Their purpose is to attract attention to the leader or the cult's ruling elite. Their result is self-gratifying behavior on the part of the leaders and ignorance on the part of naive followers.

Paul describes the false teaching in verse 14 with two terms. The first, Jewish myths, is similar to the "myths and genealogies" mentioned in 1 Timothy 1:4. Together with the reference to genealogies in 3:9, the term probably indicates a peculiar use of the Old Testament (see 1 Tim 1:4 and notes). Verse 15 implies that they were preoccupied with ritual purity, which suggests that the false doctrine had some affinity with the teaching about foods and defilement in Colosse (Col 2:16-23) and Ephesus (1 Tim 4:3). Verse 16 may reflect a claim on their part to special knowledge: they claim to know God. However, Paul's language is too general to allow us to be sure of this, and it is better to understand the statement in Jewish terms as a claim to be zealous and exacting in their approach to "the faith."

The second term in verse 14 describes the false teaching as "commands of men." This is a technical term, which goes back to Isaiah 29:13, for teaching of human origin that is added to God's revelation (the NIV somewhat obscures this nuance). Jesus picked it up in his denunciation of Jewish regulations about clean and unclean things (Mt 15:9; Mk 7:7). And Paul describes the ascetic practices in Colosse with this term (Col 2:22). Ironically, adherence to such regulations, which to the false teachers indicated holiness, was actually an indication of how far they had strayed from the truth (of the Christian message; v. 14).

Paul operated on the basis of Jesus' principle "Nothing outside a man can make him `unclean' by going into him. . . . What comes out of a man makes him `unclean' " (Mk 7:15, 20). This Paul translates in verse 15: To the pure, all things are pure, but to those who . . . do not believe, nothing is pure (compare Rom 14:14). Purity that counts comes only through faith in Christ. The heretics' obsession with external purity grew out of unbelief and rejection of the gospel. In their false teaching they cut themselves off from the One who could cleanse them. Their rejection of the truth (v. 14) signaled the corruption of their minds (v. 15). The mind, the organ of rational discernment, plays an important role in accepting the truth (1 Tim 6:5; 2 Tim 3:8). These teachers' obsessive behavior and evil motives signaled equally the corruption of their consciences, for it is by the conscience that faith and knowledge issue in behavior (see on 1 Tim 1:5; 4:2).

Ultimately, as Paul explains in verse 16, the condition of these opponents was paradoxical. Their profession to know God was contradicted by their outward behavior. The excoriating description that closes the passage heightens this paradox: (1) they are detestable, though they strive to avoid "detestable" things; (2) they are disobedient, though they strive to be exactingly obedient; and (3) they are unable to bear any spiritual fruit (good deed), though they claim to know God. One thing is clear from Paul's denunciation of the false teachers: they present a danger to the church and to themselves, a danger that cannot be ignored but must be confronted.
Opposing False Teachers

As we have seen, confronting false teaching is a task that falls to the leadership of the church. Titus and the leaders he selected were to handle this matter in Crete.

The gravity of the situation is reflected in the two commands that Paul gives. First, Titus is to "silence" (literally, "stop the mouths") of the heretics (v. 11). This must mean to "take the wind out of their sails," or to take away the momentum they had established, by publicly correcting their false doctrines with the approved teaching of the apostle. Second, he is to rebuke [correct, reprove] them sharply (v. 13). The graphic adverb used only here and in 2 Corinthians 13:10 implies the use of force that is backed up by authority. Confronting false teaching calls for decisive, firm correction, for the church's ministry and the spiritual health of believers are at stake.

But the goal of correction is not simply to protect the gospel. Correction also seeks (so that—v. 13) to restore the erring one to spiritual health (1 Tim 1:20; 2 Tim 2:22). Paul employs the verbal form of the term used elsewhere to describe the gospel as "health-producing" (v. 9; 1 Tim 1:10; 6:3) to convey this thought. This health comes only from acceptance of the faith. Turned around, as they were, these lying and perverse heretics could still be brought to repentance through confrontation with the true faith.

The Bible Panorama
Titus 1
V 1–4: INTRODUCTORY REMARKS Paul, bond servant and apostle, writes to his spiritual son Titus, and sends him Christian greetings having emphasised the importance of faith, truth, godliness, eternal life, God’s faithfulness, preaching His Word, and his own commission to obey his Saviour.
V 5–9: IMPORTANT RESPONSIBILITIES Titus had been left in Crete to help organise the churches in each city and appoint elders. Elders (the same as bishops) are to be spiritually mature and godly men whose essential characteristics and abilities are spelled out to Titus by Paul. Theirs is an important responsibility in the churches, and so is that of Titus in appointing them on Paul’s behalf. They must be able to hold, teach and defend the truth of God’s Word.
 V 10–16: INTERNAL REBELS Insubordinate, idle, deceiving, self-seeking, false teachers—many of whom are Jewish legalists—are to be opposed and rebuked, so that the Christians acquire a soundness in the faith of God. Jewish fables and man-made commands are to be opposed. The false teachers’ wicked, self-seeking, materialistic and disobedient lifestyles disqualify them from any good work, obviously including eldership, as they profess to know God but show by the way they live that they do not know Him.
Dictionary of Bible Themes
8749 false teachers

Those who teach error and in so doing lead others astray. They are to be distinguished from false prophets who are equally condemned in Scripture.
The OT prophets warned God’s people against being led astray by false teachers
Isa 9:16; Eze 34:2 See also Isa 3:12; Isa 8:20; Jer 2:8; Jer 10:21; Jer 23:1; Eze 22:26; Mal 2:7-8
Jesus Christ condemned false teachers
He opposed legalism and hypocrisy Mt 5:19
He identified the teachers of the law and Pharisees as false teachers Mt 23:1-33 pp Lk 11:42-52 See also Mt 15:14
He warned his followers against them Mt 16:6,12 pp Mk 8:15 pp Lk 12:1
The condemnation of false teachers in the early church
Paul urges his readers to avoid false teachers 1Ti 6:3-6 See also Ac 20:29-31; Ro 16:17-18; 2Co 11:3-4 The Corinthian church had been undiscerningly tolerant of Jewish deceivers in their midst; Eph 4:14 The Colossian heresy taught that the combination of faith in Jesus Christ with man-made regulations was necessary for salvation: Col 2:4,8 Paul warns against the heretical teachers in the Ephesian church: 1Ti 1:3-4,7
1Ti 4:1-3; 1Ti 6:20-21; Tit 1:10-11; Heb 13:9; 2Jn 9-10 The Nicolaitans: Rev 2:6,15
Rev 2:14 the followers of Balaam; Rev 2:20
Hymenaeus and Philetus are cited as examples of false teachers 2Ti 2:17-18
Those who teach will be judged particularly strictly Jas 3:1 See also 2Co 11:13-15; Gal 1:6-9; Gal 5:10
In comparison
7789 shepherd, as church leader

Church leaders are likened to shepherds, on account of their pastoral responsibilities and tasks.

Jesus Christ, the archetypal shepherd

1Pe 5:4
Appointment of shepherds

Eph 4:11 See also Mk 3:14; Ac 14:23; 1Co 12:28
Shepherd responsibilities

Feeding the flock Jn 21:15 See also Mk 6:34; Jn 21:17; 1Co 3:2; Heb 5:12-14; Jude 12

Caring for the flock Jn 21:16 See also Mt 25:36; Ac 20:28; Php 1:1; 1Ti 3:1-2; 2Ti 1:17; Tit 1:7; Jas 1:27; 1Pe 5:2

Protecting, from false teachers Ac 20:29 See also Mt 7:15; Jn 10:1,10

Leading, not exploiting 1Pe 5:3

Being accountable See also Heb 13:17

Risking death Jn 10:15; Ac 12:1-4; Ac 21:13



Yours by His Grace

Blair Humphreys,  Southport, Merseyside

19th August 2015

No comments:

Today's post

Jesus Christ, The Same Yesterday, Today and Forever

I had the privilege to be raised in a Christian Home and had the input of my parents and grandparents into my life, they were ...